What Conservatism Has to Say About Business Ethics
Contemporary societies face persistent concerns about declining trust, weakened communities and institutions, social fragmentation, and the human consequences of economic upheaval. Such concerns have long occupied conservative thinkers. Yet despite its undeniable relevance to business and commercial life, the conservative intellectual tradition is strikingly underrepresented within research on business ethics.
Conservatism is one of the defining political ideologies of our time. It emphasises values such as order, freedom, community, tradition, patriotism, and pragmatism. These themes have acquired renewed significance in recent years as the rise of right-wing populist movements has prompted debate about the nature and future of conservatism itself. At a time when some conservatives worry that their tradition is being eclipsed by such populist movements or by market fundamentalism, there is a particular need to renew conservative reflection on work, commercial life, and justice within capitalist society.
The absence of conservatism in business ethics is particularly puzzling since, in the UK and elsewhere, ‘the Conservatives have been the default party of business’. Furthermore, business ethics is itself sometimes characterised as being implicitly conservative. Yet, while research on business ethics has drawn on a wide array of thinkers from the history of moral and political philosophy, explicit engagement with conservative thought has been almost entirely absent.
What might a conservative approach look like? Our research focuses on the British Tory tradition, and on Burke, Oakeshott, and Scruton, figures who are central to this tradition, in particular. Within this tradition, political society is conceived of as a valuable inheritance, a partnership that exists across generations. Conservative thought emphasises the importance of local affiliation, the small-scale, the familiar. In this way at least, conservatism can be understood as a personal ethical disposition rather than a narrowly ‘party political’ stance.
Conservatism is distinct from libertarianism. The two traditions have often found themselves politically aligned, but remain ‘uneasy cousins’. For libertarians, freedom is the overriding good. By contrast, conservatism tends to be sceptical of abstract rights and universalist principles and accordingly tends to view freedom as one good among many. On this view, freedom without restraint erodes the cultural and ethical preconditions that make ordered liberty possible.
Many conservatives have regarded capitalism as an important part of our social inheritance, and something worthy of preservation insofar as it supports freedom, enterprise, and prosperity. But this admiration for markets has limits. Conservatives have, perhaps surprisingly, at times been capable critics of capitalism. Conservative criticisms of contemporary capitalism might focus on the lack of rootedness and accountability characteristic of large, multinational enterprises, or on the provision of goods and services that cater to what Burke would have called ‘disorderly appetites’. Work, too, should be productive and profitable but also conceived of as potentially meaningful, an end in itself, because workers are also fellow citizens.
Taken together, these themes point towards a distinctive set of institutions and practices that conservatives might regard as especially worthy of ethical attention. Conservatives value smaller-scale institutions, of which the family business is a paradigmatic example. Family firms are not only economic actors but also mediating institutions that transmit values, traditions, and responsibilities across generations. From a conservative perspective, provisions such as parental leave, flexible working arrangements, and a living wage can best be seen as safeguards for the intergenerational continuity of society itself. Even environmentalism may find a conservative voice, since it can emerge from a commitment to preservation and an attachment to place. Such examples highlight the possibility of agreement across political perspectives, and away from the apparently intractable disagreements of the so-called ‘culture wars’.
Our key message is that conservative thought deserves to be taken seriously in debates about business ethics. Indeed, even those with a deep and enduring opposition to conservative politics may find value in better understanding the conservative tradition. At the same time, conservatives concerned with the future of their own tradition have good reason to engage more seriously with questions of work, business, and economic life. Whether conservative arguments ultimately succeed is less important than ensuring that they are part of the conversation.
- Matthew Sinnicks is associate professor at University of Southampton Business School. His research interests include flourishing and alienation in the workplace, the ethical quality of work, and the concept of tradition as it relates to business and organizations. His recent work has appeared in journals such as Business Ethics Quarterly, Journal of Business Ethics, Academy of Management Perspectives, and Academy of Management Learning & Education.
- Caleb Bernacchio is the Legendre-Soulé Chair in Business Ethics, associate professor of management, and faculty director of the Center for Ethics and Economic Justice at Loyola University New Orleans. His research focuses on neo-Aristotelian virtue ethics and organization theory. He has published widely on related topics in journals such as Academy of Management Annals, Academy of Management Review, Acta Philosophica, Business Ethics Quarterly, and Journal of Business Ethics.