Search Comment Central
Brexit Mini Edited

Brexiteers are running scared #Bregrexit

Neil Carmichael
August 8, 2018

Former Conservative MP, Neil Carmichael believes the public should have the opportunity to pass judgement on the outcome of the Government's Brexit negotiations.

The binary choice offered to the British people during the Referendum just over two years ago has spawned countless more choices as complexities, contradictions and consequences just keep on coming to the fore. The process is made even more difficult simply because the United Kingdom is leaving of its own volition but without a real plan and is negotiating with an admittedly surprised but also resolute and clear-sighted European Union.

By way of illustration, the no-deal option – favoured by Brexit purists and, ironically, close to the promises in the ill-fated Conservative 2017 election manifesto (out of the customs union, single market and so on) – threatens the integrity of the United Kingdom, largely because without genuine economic 'alignment' there must be a Northern Ireland border and this will have political ramifications.

The Chequers Agreement underlines another problem. Negotiations inside the Conservative Party may well excite media interest but the real negotiations continue to take place in Brussels. While some of the details of the Agreement are plausible the complete package is not deliverable – risking the situation where nobody is completely satisfied with anything.

A deal is still possible but, with so many red lines almost literally inked in with permanent markers, this would amount to a Canada-type trade arrangement between the UK and the EU. At the very least, this would be damaging to the UK's massive service sector and is likely to take years to negotiate, leaving the UK in a long-term state of anxiety.  Moreover, with all our other trade treaties also being voided, we face multiple other negotiations all from a position of weakness.

It is often asserted that the electorate did not vote in the Referendum to be poorer. Actually, it did, though it wasn't aware of that, given the noise and false promises of the Leave campaign. Now it is becoming increasingly aware of the political and economic risks ahead and, as the polls show, discontent with the Brexit process is rising inexorably, with a majority of voters now wanting to Remain and favouring a new popular vote. Voters are right. The proposed outcome from the Brexit process should be put to the electorate because it will not be all that was expected and is likely to result in a huge disappointment – complete with serious implications for the national interest.

Neil Carmichael is the former MP for Stroud (2010-17) and is the President of Conservatives for a People's Vote. 


Neil Carmichael is Honorary Professor of Politics and Education, University of Nottingham; Senior Adviser at PLMR; Chair, Commission on Sustainable Learning for Work, Life and a Changing Economy; President of Conservatives for a People’s Vote; and, former Member of Parliament for Stroud and chair of the Education Select Committee.

Most Popular
Image: Pexels / Olga Lioncat
The economy is not doing...
Max Mosley 1
Max Mosley
February 28, 2024
Image: Pexels / Markus Spiske
Kemi Badenoch falsely claims to...
Peter Tatchell
Peter Tatchell
March 1, 2024
What to read next
51895225543 b332145540 o 1
The Government must not continue to disregard the seriousness of the...
Jayne Adye
March 10, 2022
Shutterstock 1230782722 1
As the new Minister for Brexit Opportunities, Jacob Rees-Mogg’s priority should...
Jayne Adye
February 10, 2022
Shutterstock 791976160 1
Recent successes have shown just what a ‘Global Britain’ can achieve....
Jayne Adye
January 28, 2022