Search Comment Central
Parliament Churchill Silhouette Edited

Brexit Bill essential for No Deal Brexit

John Redwood MP
November 17, 2017

The EU Withdrawal bill is essential, says John Redwood, as it provides the certainty and continuity of law we need given it now seems inevitable we will not be leaving with an agreement in place.

The date of our departure from the EU is determined by the EU Treaty. Under Article 50 we gave notice. We leave at any time when there is agreement between the UK and the rest of the EU, or at the two-year point should there be no agreement.

It now looks clear that the EU has no wish to reach a mutually beneficial agreement to get us out of the EU before March 2019. They are still refusing to discuss the future relationship and trade arrangements which the UK thinks is in our mutual interest to discuss.

The question now comes up for debate in Parliament about when the UK needs to bring into full effect the EU Withdrawal Bill to ensure legal continuity and certainty following our departure. The government is therefore moving an amendment to make the time and date 11pm on 29th March 2019.

This should not be contentious. It is the date and time we will cease to be a member state under the Treaty and Article 50 procedure. The reason it also needs to be written into the Withdrawal Bill is that we need to bring in its provisions at the same time as we cease to belong to the EU in international law. Domestic law has to take over. It is also the likely earliest time when there could be an agreement.

So why is it a matter of grave concern to some MPs that the government wishes to ensure this legal continuity? For the rest of the Bill they are desperate to ensure anything is debated in Bill Committee and does go through full legislative scrutiny, yet they don't want to do the same for the important matter of when we leave. The reason seems to be that they think we might get into the position where we are very close to an Agreement by 29 March 2019 but would somehow be thwarted in concluding shortly afterwards if we had in the meantime left the EU. It is difficult to see why this should occur. We have 16 months prior to departure to try to reach an agreement. That agreement could include an implementation period to follow exit if it required changes that are difficult to put in place quickly. The government has already said there will be additional legislation for any agreement to be implemented in the UK.

I cannot see having a deadline 16 months ahead makes it more difficult to conclude an Agreement. If the EU does want a mutually beneficial Agreement there is plenty of time to get one. If the EU does not really want one or intends to try to squeeze more and more concessions out of the UK, an extension of a week or two after March 2019 is not going to suddenly provide a suitable agreement after months of failure.

When Parliament legislated to send the Article 50 letter for us to leave in March 2019. The main reason we want that on the face of the Withdrawal Bill is to provide certainty and continuity of law given it now seems inevitable we will not be leaving by agreement any earlier.

On Tuesday the crucial Clause 1 which repeals the 1972 Act and therefore takes us out of the EU according to UK law passed by 318 to 68. The official Labour party abstained, as they realised voting against would be to vote against Brexit itself. The rest of the Bill is about creating legal certainty by carry over of EU laws.

Portrait 2023 03 23 151346 tcwc

John Redwood is the Conservative MP for Wokingham and a former Secretary of State for Wales.

Border
Most Popular
Pexels / Louis Bauer
Victims of sodium valproate, vaginal...
Natalie Bennett
Baroness Natalie Bennett
March 14, 2024
What to read next
EV
The electrical revolution many seek needs huge investment....
Portrait 2023 03 23 151346 tcwc
John Redwood MP
September 20, 2023
As the government looks to use some of our Brexit freedoms...
Portrait 2023 03 23 151346 tcwc
John Redwood MP
May 23, 2023
If the UK wants to persist with its model of independent...
Portrait 2023 03 23 151346 tcwc
John Redwood MP
April 2, 2023